AI generated content has become a hot topic in the world of digital marketing, raising questions about its impact on search engine rankings. While AI can streamline content creation and boost efficiency, concerns remain about its ability to meet SEO standards.
Is AI content bad for SEO? Or can it rank just as well as human written content? Search engines prioritize high quality, user focused content, no matter the source. This blog examines whether AI content negatively impacts SEO, its potential challenges, and best practices to use AI.
Is AI Content Bad for SEO? And Can It Negatively Impact Rankings?
AIgenerated content is not inherently bad for SEO, but its effectiveness depends on how it is used.
Currently, Google has stated that AI generated content does not impact search rankings. The key factor is content quality, as long as your content is helpful, original, and relevant, it has the potential to rank well.
Google focuses more on what your content delivers rather than how it’s created.
Insights from Google
At Google, we’ve long believed in the power of AI to transform the ability to deliver helpful information.
What Are the Real World Results?
We dug into this topic, and here’s what we found:
- A survey of over 700 marketers found that 39% experienced increased website traffic after using AI written content. 33% reported that their AI generated content outperformed human written content.
- An experiment revealed that 70.95% of new pages with AI generated content were indexed by Google within the first 36 days. Additionally, 8 out of 20 new websites featuring AI content began ranking for over 1,000 keywords each within a month.
So, what separates the winners from the rest? The most successful AI assisted content adheres to Google’s EEAT framework, which prioritizes:
✅ Experience: Content that shows firsthand knowledge or insights.
✅ Expertise: Well researched, in depth information.
✅ Authoritativeness: Published on a reputable, high quality site.
✅ Trustworthiness: Reliable, fact checked content with accurate sources.
AI can be a powerful tool, but it’s not a magic formula. Those who blend AI with human expertise and follow EEAT principles see the best results. AI should enhance your content, not replace strategic thinking and originality.
How Does AI Impact User Engagement?
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing content creation, but how does it impact user engagement? Recent experiments provide valuable insights into this question.
SEOwind conducted a 30 day experiment where they published 100 AI generated articles on their domain. The results were noteworthy:
- Clicks: An increase of 77.7%, rising from approximately 1,300 to nearly 2,400 clicks per month.
- Impressions: A boost of 125%, indicating enhanced visibility in search results.
These findings suggest that AI generated content, when executed thoughtfully, can significantly enhance user engagement and organic traffic.
In another study, SE Ranking published six AI assisted articles over six months, achieving the following outcomes:
- Impressions: Nearly 138,000.
- Clicks: Over 860.
Notably, three of these articles ranked in the top 10 organic search results, demonstrating AI’s potential in producing high ranking content.
Here’s why human oversight remains crucial and how it played a role in the success of these experiments. Both experiments involved:
- Keyword Research: Identifying relevant topics and search terms.
- Content Optimization: Enhancing readability and SEO elements.
- Editing: Ensuring accuracy and coherence.
This collaboration between AI efficiency and human expertise leads to content that resonates with audiences and performs well in search rankings.
What Impact Does AI Have on Content Performance?
The impact of AI on content performance varies widely among users. According to industry insights, 34% of professionals report that AI has helped improve their content performance, enhancing engagement and visibility.
However, 19% see no significant difference, suggesting that AI’s effectiveness depends on factors like implementation, content type, and optimization strategies. On the other hand, 6% believe AI has negatively impacted their content, possibly due to human oversight.
These mixed results highlight that while AI can be a powerful tool, its success depends on how well it is integrated into the content creation process.
Beyond rankings and engagement, 29% of respondents say AI doesn’t necessarily boost ROI but significantly accelerates content creation, especially in brainstorming and headline generation. Every writer knows the struggle of hitting a creative block, and AI helps overcome that hurdle.
A Danish news outlet, TV 2 Fyn, conducted A/B tests using ChatGPT generated headlines to improve click through rates (CTR). Over three weeks between late 2022 and early 2023, they ran 46 A/B tests comparing AI written vs human written headlines.
Results:
📈 AI generated headlines outperformed human created ones in 46% of tests.
📉 Human headlines won in just 24% of cases.
🚀 Some AI driven headlines led to over a 100% increase in CTR.
Ultimately, AI powered headlines boosted CTR by 59%, showing that AI can enhance engagement, but human refinement and optimization are still essential.
6 Effective Strategies for Using AI Generated Content
AI generated content has transformed the way businesses create and distribute content, offering efficiency and scalability. However, leveraging AI effectively requires a balanced approach that includes human oversight, transparency, and strategic application.
Here’s how to maximize the benefits of AI generated content while overcoming its limitations.
Be Transparent About AI Usage
One of the most crucial aspects of integrating AI into content creation is transparency. As AI becomes more prevalent, audiences appreciate knowing when and how AI has been used. Simply acknowledging AI’s role in content production fosters trust and credibility.
Openly disclose when AI has been used in content creation reinforcing authenticity with their audience. A simple line such as “This article was created with AI assistance and refined by our editorial team” can go a long way in maintaining trust while utilizing AI’s efficiency.
Prioritize Thought Leadership Over AI Dependence
While AI can help generate content quickly, it should not replace human driven thought leadership. AI lacks the ability to establish a brand’s voice, engage in complex discussions, or create authentic connections with audiences.
According to Lindsay Tjepkema, CEO of Casted, AI is a short term fix but not a sustainable way to build brand authority. Instead, businesses should focus on human centric content strategies, such as podcasts, webinars, and video content, while using AI to support distribution and amplification.
AI can assist with repurposing this thought leadership content into blogs or social media posts, but the core insights should always come from human expertise.
Monitor and Refine AI Driven Automations
AI is revolutionizing content workflows by automating SEO optimization, keyword research, and content structuring. Platforms like Meta have doubled their monthly search traffic using AI powered SEO tools to identify search trends, optimize metadata, and fix website errors.
However, as AI takes on more automated tasks, human oversight remains essential. AI driven SEO improvements must still be reviewed and refined by experienced SEO professionals to ensure quality and strategic alignment.
Businesses should continuously test AI generated insights, adjust strategies based on real world performance, and prevent over reliance on automation.
Use AI for Targeted Content Creation
Rather than using AI to mass produce generic content, brands should leverage AI for targeted content strategies.
ScrapingBee, for example, uses AI to analyze search trends, monitor competitors, and identify content gaps, allowing them to create highly specific, data driven content tailored to user needs.
Maintain Human Involvement in Content Structuring
While AI can assist with research, ideation, and writing, structuring content should remain a human driven process.
According to Antonio Černeli, founder of Peakflow Agency, one of the biggest mistakes marketers make is trying to condense six hours of research, structuring, and ideation into a 15 minute AI task.
AI cannot determine the best way to frame a topic for a brand’s unique audience, product positioning, and market conditions. Human editors must guide AI generated content, ensuring it aligns with brand goals, audience expectations, and current market trends.
Prune Low Value AI Generated Content
Not all AI generated content performs well, and sometimes removing low performing posts is necessary for SEO success. Userpilot, for example, pruned 847 blog posts, many of which were AI generated and failed to drive meaningful engagement.
The result was a 16% traffic boost, proving that quality outweighs quantity. Brands should regularly audit their content, removing outdated, low traffic, or low converting pieces to maintain a high value content ecosystem.
Instead of relying on AI to create content in bulk, businesses should focus on curating and refining AIgenerated pieces for maximum impact.
What are The Challenges of AI Generated Content for SEO?
AI generated content has become a valuable tool for efficiency, but it comes with several drawbacks that can negatively impact SEO rankings, audience engagement, and even legal risks. Below are some key limitations that content creators should consider before relying solely on AI.
Inaccurate & Misleading Information
One of the biggest risks of AI generated content is factual inaccuracies. Even the most advanced AI models can “hallucinate” fabricating statistics, sources, or facts that don’t exist.
📌 Why it matters:
- False information erodes trust with your audience.
- Google prioritizes accurate, well researched content.
- Publishing incorrect information, especially in finance, health, or legal niches could expose you to legal liability for false advertising or libel.
✅ Solution: Implement AI human hybrid workflows where AI suggests content, but humans refine and validate the final version.
Lacks Human Emotion & Engagement
AI struggles to convey emotion, personality, and unique storytelling, making its content less engaging than human written pieces. Readers connect with real experiences, humor, and nuanced writing, all of which AI fails to replicate effectively.
📌 Why it matters:
- Pages with low engagement & high bounce rates signal to Google that the content isn’t useful, leading to lower rankings.
- Dwell time matters, if users leave your page quickly because the content feels robotic, it harms SEO.
✅ Solution: Infuse AI generated content with personal anecdotes, brand voice, and human storytelling to increase user engagement.
Risk of Unoriginal & Duplicate Content
AI pulls from existing web content, meaning it doesn’t create anything truly new. This can lead to:
- Lack of originality: Your content may sound generic or too similar to competitors’.
- Duplicate content risks: If multiple businesses use AI for the same topic, they may produce nearly identical articles, which can hurt search rankings.
✅ Solution: Customize AI generated content by adding:
- Unique examples from your brand or clients.
- Expert insights that AI can’t provide.
- Firsthand experiences to make your content stand out.
AI Alone Can’t Meet Google’s EEAT Guidelines
Google prioritizes EEAT (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness), but AI struggles to meet these standards. It lacks first hand experience, cannot provide expert level insights, and fails to build personal credibility, key factors for ranking well.
Relying solely on AI may weaken content authority, especially in industries where trust and expertise are essential.
📌 Why it matters: AI generated content alone may not be enough to rank well, especially in high stakes niches like finance, health, and law, where Google demands high EEAT signals.
✅ Solution:
Include an authentic author profile featuring a real human expert, not a pseudonymous. Ensure that the author has a verifiable online presence, such as an active LinkedIn profile, social media engagement, or published work that reflects their industry expertise.
SEO Over Optimization & Keyword Stuffing Risks
AI tools often overuse keywords in unnatural ways, leading to keyword stuffing, a practice penalized by Google. Content must be optimized for readers first, search engines second.
✅ Solution: AI generated drafts should always go through human editing to ensure natural keyword integration.
Case Studies: Is AI Content Bad for SEO?
AI generated content has shown both success and failure in SEO performance. While some businesses have leveraged AI to boost rankings and engagement, others have faced credibility issues and traffic declines due to poor quality control.
These case studies highlight the importance of human oversight in AI assisted content creation.
Success Story: HubSpot Generated AI Content To Increases SEO Rankings
HubSpot tested AI generated blog posts against human written content and found that AI assisted articles ranked faster and performed well in organic search.
However, the key success factor was human oversight, where editors refined AI outputs to match brand voice, improve readability, and add unique insights. The study concluded that AI can enhance productivity if combined with strategic human intervention.
Failed AI Experiment: Gizmodo AI Content Leads to Traffic Decline
Gizmodo experimented with AI generated news articles but faced severe backlash due to factual errors and poor readability. Many articles contained historical inaccuracies and awkward phrasing, leading to user complaints and credibility issues.
Google did not explicitly penalize the content, but the site experienced lower engagement and a drop in organic traffic, proving that AI written content without proper fact checking can damage a publication’s reputation.
These case studies illustrate that AI can boost content success when used strategically but can harm credibility if left unchecked. Let me know if you need more insights!
The “AI Watermark” Phenomenon: Could Google Detect AI Content at Scale?
While Google states it does not penalize AI content by default, there’s speculation about an AI watermarking system in its algorithm.
Hypothesis
AI generated content often follows predictable patterns: rigid sentence structures, passive tone, keyword overuse, repetitive phrasing, and lack of storytelling depth. If Google refines its algorithms to detect these traits, AI driven content could be flagged and rankings adjusted accordingly.
SEO Risk: Could AI Generated Content Be Penalized?
While AI content isn’t explicitly penalized, Google prioritizes originality, depth, and engagement. If detected as low value or redundant, AI driven content may face:
- Ranking Drops: AI heavy sites may experience fluctuations if content lacks uniqueness.
- Lower Authority: Expert driven industries (finance, health) could struggle against human written content.
- Reduced Visibility: Predictable, AI generated articles may be deprioritized in favor of human driven insights.
To avoid AI detection and maintain SEO performance, businesses should refine AI generated drafts with manual edits, breaking predictable patterns and varying sentence structures.
Adding storytelling elements like firsthand experiences, case studies, and expert insights enhances authenticity and engagement. Diversifying sentence lengths, using structured formatting, and maintaining a natural flow improve readability.
Explore More SEO Guides
- Remove Negative Articles from Google: Flag each review request removal for cleaner ratings.
- Social Media SEO: Optimize social profiles, increase visibility, attract loyal customers.
- Google Ranking Dropped Dramatically: Identify ranking drops and implement recovery strategies for better search visibility.
- How to Increase Website Traffic: Boost organic visits with strategic SEO and content optimization.
- Semantic SEO: Optimize content with intent-driven strategies for better search visibility.
FAQs
Is AI generated content against Google Search's guidelines?
Why doesn’t Google Search prohibit AI generated content?
Should I use AI for content creation?
How does Google handle AI enerated content that may spread misinformation or contradict widely accepted facts?
How does Google detect AI generated spam in search results?
Can AI be listed as the author of content?
Should I disclose the use of AI or automation in my content?
Conclusion
AI generated content isn’t inherently bad for SEO, but its effectiveness depends on quality, originality, and human oversight. While AI can streamline content creation, relying solely on it risks inaccuracies, lack of engagement, and SEO penalties.
The key to answering “Is AI Content Bad for SEO?” lies in strategic use, fact checking, refining, and infusing human expertise. When balanced correctly, AI can be a powerful tool for scalable, SEOfriendly content without compromising quality or rankings.
